Key Takeaways
- To measure the ROI of your apprenticeship program, decide what you will track before the apprentice starts.
- A one-page scorecard reviewed each quarter is enough for most small businesses.
- Record costs and benefits separately, then compare them using the same time period.
- Include feedback from the apprentice and the supervisor alongside the numbers.
- Use official sources for current employer support, because it changes.
Introduction
If you want to measure the ROI of your apprenticeship program, the simplest approach is to start with a scorecard you fill in on a set date every quarter. That habit is more useful than a large one-off analysis, because it shows how things change as the apprentice learns.
This post is about the practical routine. For the bigger picture of what return on investment means for a business that trains its own people, read our overview of the real ROI of growing your own workforce. Future1st is a Melbourne group training organisation that recruits, employs and places apprentices and trainees with Victorian businesses, and the scorecard works whether you hire directly or through a group training organisation.
Step 1: Choose Your Goal Before Day One
Your goal decides your measures. Pick one or two.
- Fill a skills gap in your team.
- Reduce time spent on recruitment.
- Build a pipeline of people trained in your methods.
- Free experienced staff from routine tasks.
Write the goal at the top of the scorecard. If you cannot say what you want, the numbers will not mean much.
Step 2: Set a Baseline
A baseline is a snapshot of where things are before the apprentice starts. Without it, you cannot show change.
- How many hours do your experienced staff spend on routine tasks?
- How often does work need to be redone?
- How long does it take to fill a vacancy?
- How long do customers wait?
Use your own records or a reasonable estimate. Write down how you got each number.
Step 3: List the Costs
Record costs in categories so nothing is missed.
- Apprentice wages and any on-costs.
- Supervision time, which is often the biggest hidden cost.
- Training costs, tools, equipment and uniforms.
- Administration, such as payroll and training paperwork. If a group training organisation is the employer, Future1st handles payroll and training administration, so this line looks different.
Costs and employer support change, so check current information on the Australian Government employer financial support page rather than copying an old figure.
Step 4: Choose Three to Five Measures
Pick a short list that links to your goal. Too many measures makes the scorecard a chore.
- Output: tasks the apprentice completes without help.
- Quality: errors, rework or complaints on their work.
- Time released: hours experienced staff gain for higher-value work.
- Progress: units or competencies completed in the qualification.
- Engagement: attendance, attitude and confidence, as seen by the supervisor.
Our post on key metrics for evaluating the impact of trainee programs has more ideas.
Step 5: Review Each Quarter
Put a fixed date in the diary. At each review:
- Fill in the measures from your records.
- Ask the apprentice what is going well and what is unclear.
- Ask the supervisor what support they need.
- Note one change to try before the next review.
A short conversation is often as valuable as the figures. Future1st field officers visit workplaces and training institutes to monitor progress, so share your scorecard findings with your contact if something looks off.
Step 6: Turn It Into a Return
After a full year, or at the end of the apprenticeship, compare what you spent with what you gained. The usual formula is: ROI equals benefits minus costs, divided by costs, which gives you a ratio you can express as a percentage.
Be careful with the benefit side.
- Count only benefits you can link to the apprenticeship.
- Put a value on released staff time using your own pay costs.
- List the harder-to-price gains separately, such as stronger culture, a trained future team member or less recruitment effort.
- Be open about assumptions, so you can adjust them later.
If the result is lower than you hoped, look at supervision, task planning and fit before you conclude the program is not worth it. A written training plan with named tasks and a named teacher for each one often makes the biggest difference.
Related Resources
Frequently Asked Questions
What is ROI for an apprenticeship program?
It compares what the program costs you with what it returns, in money and in other benefits such as time released and skills built.
How often should I review it?
Each quarter is a good rhythm. It is frequent enough to catch problems and spaced enough to see change.
Do I need software to track it?
Not at first. A spreadsheet and a calendar reminder are enough for most small businesses.
Can I measure the benefits that are not financial?
Yes, but keep them separate from the dollar figure. Use supervisor and apprentice feedback and record specific examples.
Who handles payroll and training paperwork?
If Future1st is the employer, Future1st handles payroll and training administration. The host business provides day-to-day work and supervision.
Start the Scorecard Before Your Apprentice Does
Set the goal and baseline now, and the first review will be far more useful. To discuss hiring an apprentice through Future1st, see the hire an apprentice page or call (03) 9656 9797.